Roofing DIY & Homeowner Tips

8 Common Ways A Roof Replacement Goes Wrong, Even with Experience

When it comes time to invest in a roof replacement, research is a homeowner’s best friend. But once you start digging into all the different aspects of the project—materials, warranties, costs, ventilation, etc.—research can become overwhelming.

Finding a roof replacement contractor that you trust is as important as the individual components of the project. Doing your homework to find the best partner for the project can ensure every other decision is an effective one.

The problem is that many homeowners struggle to differentiate between roof replacement contractors.

Still, choosing the right contractor can be all the difference between a successful project and one marred by common mistakes. As you work through the planning process, keep these 8 mistakes in mind that even the most experienced roofers can make.

1. Failing to Use Starter Strips


No roof replacement should be done without an underlying starter layer of adhesive strips. Without starter strips, you have to install shingles directly to the frame, leaving the roof susceptible to wind and other elements.

Your roof is supposed to last you decades. Don’t let a simple step like starter strips result in shingles blowing off just a few months or years into the roof’s lifespan.

2. Skipping the Ice and Water Shield


For years now, sealing roof eaves during replacements with ice and water shield has been a standard practice. However, “old-school” contractors may opt for more traditional underlayment.

You want to be sure that your roof replacement contractor is installing ice and water shield in vulnerable areas, especially in a wet climate like Maryland. Without it, you may be at greater risk of seeing leaks and water damage.

3. Relying on Low-Quality Pipe Collars


Rooftop vents are essential for filtering gas out of your kitchen and bathrooms. However, ventilation pipes have become common components to blame for rooftop leaks.

That’s because many roof replacement contractors install collars around the bases of these pipes that aren’t suited for a long lifespan. Aside from rapid wear-and-tear, contractors can make mistakes when cutting collars to size. Even a slight miscalculation can lead to cracks that expand over time and let more water under the roofing materials.

4. Trusting Caulking for Water Resistance


In many renovations, contractors trust caulking to create waterproof seals. Whether it’s around windows, doors, in kitchens, or in bathrooms, caulking is a must-have for just about any project.

However, roof replacement contractors often make the mistake of trusting caulking for water resistance. Caulking will shrink and expand as weather changes, leading to cracks over time. These cracks will let water seep into the roof and cause further damage.

It’s better to trust a proper flashing system coupled with a true waterproof/resistant underlayment and flashing for protection against the elements.

5. Adding Layers in the Wrong Order


For most homeowners, a roof replacement may seem like it’s all about the shingles. However, there’s much more to the project than just the top layer.

Every roof replacement contractor knows the layers necessary for success. But a common mistake is to add a layer out of order, compromising overall protection.

Generally, the order should start with the eave and move to the drip edge, followed by ice/water guard and underlayment. Then, contractors should add flashing, shingles, and ventilation.

6. Overdoing the Flashing


Step flashing has become a common technique for improving water resistance across a new roof. This process includes a woven installation of flashing and shingles rather than a more traditional layered approach.

The only problem is that some contractors will go overboard during installation. Some contractors may make mistakes trying to weave flashing and shingles together. Others may nail flashing to both walls and the roof deck. Both missteps can create gaps in what was supposed to be a water-tight seal.

7. Using the Wrong Fastener Length


It may seem obvious, but the nails used to fasten shingles to your roof deck must be the proper length.

During busy seasons, contractors may get caught up between projects and make a mistake by using fasteners that are just too short. This results in loose shingles that either blow off in the wind or allow water to seep into the home. Either way, it’s something you (and your contractor) want to avoid.

8. Neglecting the Roof Deck


Decking acts as the foundation for your roof replacement. If it’s weak, the quality of installation won’t matter because your entire roof could be compromised.

Roof replacement contractors may overlook deficiencies of existing decking, moving forward with the foundation rather than building a new one. You may save money this way in the short-term, but overall, you’ll end up with a sub-par roof replacement.

Make sure any roof replacement contractors properly inspect the decking to decide whether it needs to be replaced as well.

Finding a Roof Replacement Contractor You Trust

Unfortunately, too many homeowners discover their contractors made these mistakes after the fact. It’s not as if a potential partner will come out and explain all the mistakes they’ve made in the past.

That’s why it is important to be vigilant in the research phase. Be picky and ask a lot of questions before choosing a roof replacement contractor. And remember, the best contractors will take steps to understand everything about your project, inspecting the roof and working with you to determine your true needs.

 

left right
Recent Articles
Who to Call for Your Home Improvement Project: Contractor vs. Full-Service Remodeler
Choosing who to hire for your home remodeling project can be stressful. Depending on the work you need done, there could be hundreds of options in...
Home Living
Read More
Maintenance Tips for Your Vinyl Siding
Vinyl siding is the most popular siding option in the United States with good reason. It comes in a variety of colors and styles, is quite durable,...
DIY & Homeowner Tips
Read More
Checklist: Five Areas of Your Home to Inspect Every Fall
While spring is usually associated with fresh home repairs, fall preparations can save you from costly problems when winter storms and freezing...
DIY & Homeowner Tips
Read More
Fall Gutter Cleaning Tips: When to DIY and When to Call the Pros
With falling leaves and the remnants of summer storms, fall is an important time to inspect and clean out your gutters. Debris and water sitting in...
DIY & Homeowner Tips
Read More
How to Extend the Life of Your Roof
Your roof is a critical component of your home, keeping you dry during heavy spring storms and warm in freezing winter temperatures. Even though it...
Roofing
Read More
Is It Time to Replace Your Windows? What to Look for
Even high quality, professionally installed windows have a set lifespan. The windows on your home can last around 10 years, maybe a bit longer if...
Education
Read More
Why Fall is a Good Time to Replace Your Roof
With over 30 years of experience working on Maryland roofs, Brothers roofing consultants are often asked, "what is the best time of year to replace...
Roofing
Read More
8 Important Questions to Ask Before Finishing Your Basement
Many homeowners think basement finishing will be a simple project. It's just putting down some flooring and hanging drywall, right? Well, that's a...
Read More
Vinyl Siding: What’s on the Outside Counts
Modern vinyl siding has come a long way from the practical but boring beige slabs that coated suburban homes, making them indistinguishable from one...
Home Living
Read More